A Fever in the Heartland

Timothy Egan

Full starFull starFull starFull starHalf star
4.6(6,776 Ratings)
Left wheat earsGoodreads Choice AwardsRight wheat ears
Left wheat earsApple BooksRight wheat ears
3 Months Free TrialArrow right
Clock72 Min Reading Time
MicrophoneAudio Version Available
cover backgroundA Fever in the Heartland

About this book

In the shadow of the Roaring Twenties, a uniquely American evil took root. While flappers danced to jazz, the Ku Klux Klan rose to terrifying power not in the Old Confederacy, but in the Heartland and the West, fueled by hatred against Blacks, Jews, Catholics, and immigrants. At the center of this surge stood D.C. Stephenson, a charismatic con man who became the Grand Dragon of Indiana, his gospel of hate spread from pulpits to town squares, embraced by judges, governors, and senators. But when Stephenson's cruelty led to the tragic death of Madge Oberholtzer, her courageous deathbed testimony exposed his dark secrets and brought the Klan crashing down. A Fever in the Heartland, by Pulitzer and National Book Award-winning author Timothy Egan, is a propulsive historical thriller and a chillingly resonant reckoning with a sinister chapter in American history, revealing how easily hatred can be disguised and the power of one woman to ignite the spark of justice.

Summary of Key Ideas

  • The Klan's Explosive Growth

    The Second Klan's Rapid Ascent: Egan meticulously details the resurgence of the Ku Klux Klan in the 1920s, highlighting its transformation from a fringe group into a powerful social and political force. This rise was fueled by anxieties related to immigration, urbanization, and changing social norms. The Klan exploited these fears, offering a sense of belonging and order to those feeling marginalized by the rapid changes of the era. The book emphasizes how the Klan's message resonated across various segments of society, attracting not only the poor and uneducated but also middle-class professionals and community leaders.

  • Indiana: Klan Stronghold

    Indiana as the Epicenter: Egan pinpoints Indiana as the unlikely heartland of Klan activity during this period. Factors such as a large native-born white population, a history of racial prejudice, and a weak political structure contributed to the Klan's dominance in the state. The book explores how the Klan effectively infiltrated Indiana's government, law enforcement, and even religious institutions, wielding significant influence over policy and public life. This focus on Indiana provides a microcosm for understanding the Klan's broader appeal and impact across the nation.

  • The Grand Dragon's Fall

    D.C. Stephenson's Corrupt Leadership: The book centers around the figure of D.C. Stephenson, the Grand Dragon of the Indiana Klan, as a key driver of the organization's success and eventual downfall. Egan portrays Stephenson as a charismatic yet deeply flawed individual who used the Klan to amass personal wealth and political power. His corruption, abuse of authority, and eventual conviction for murder exposed the hypocrisy at the heart of the Klan's moralistic rhetoric, contributing significantly to its decline.

  • Klan Hypocrisy Unveiled

    Hypocrisy and Moral Decay: Egan exposes the stark contrast between the Klan's proclaimed values of morality and patriotism and the reality of its members' behavior. Through detailed accounts of corruption, violence, and sexual scandals, the book reveals the hypocrisy that undermined the Klan's credibility. This exposure of moral decay within the organization played a crucial role in disillusioning members and eroding public support.

  • Women's Fight Against Hate

    The Power of Women's Resistance: While the book focuses on the Klan's rise and fall, it also highlights the courageous resistance of individuals who opposed the organization. The story of Madge Oberholtzer serves as a pivotal point. Her victimization by Stephenson and her brave testimony exposed his crimes and the Klan's true nature. Egan underscores the vital role women played in challenging the Klan's power and advocating for justice, often at great personal risk.

  • Historical Parallels and Contemporary Relevance

    Echoes of the Past in the Present: Egan draws parallels between the Klan's resurgence in the 1920s and contemporary political and social movements. The book suggests that the anxieties and divisions that fueled the Klan's rise – fear of outsiders, economic insecurity, and cultural change – continue to resonate in American society today. By highlighting these connections, Egan encourages readers to critically examine the present and learn from the mistakes of the past.

  • Fueling Hate Through Fear

    Exploitation of Fear and Prejudice: A central theme is how the Klan effectively manipulated existing prejudices and fears within American society to gain power and influence. The book illustrates how the Klan preyed on anxieties surrounding race, religion, and immigration, offering simplistic solutions to complex social problems. This exploitation of fear and prejudice serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of demagoguery and the importance of critical thinking.

  • Democracy Under Threat

    The Fragility of Democracy: Egan's narrative underscores the fragility of democratic institutions in the face of extremism and intolerance. The Klan's ability to infiltrate and influence government, law enforcement, and the judiciary demonstrates the vulnerability of democratic systems to organized hate movements. The book serves as a reminder of the importance of vigilance, civic engagement, and protecting the rights of all citizens to safeguard democracy.

  • The Need to Belong

    The Allure of Belonging: The book examines the psychological factors that contributed to the Klan's appeal, particularly the desire for belonging and community. In a rapidly changing society, the Klan offered a sense of identity and purpose to those feeling alienated or disenfranchised. This exploration of the allure of belonging highlights the importance of fostering inclusive communities and addressing the root causes of social isolation.

Chapter Recap

Introduction: The Quintessential AmericansOn January 12, 1925, Indiana stood as a testament to the burgeoning power of the Ku Klux Klan, personified by its Grand Dragon, David C. Stephenson. At the Inaugural Ball for the new governor, Ed Jackson, Stephenson was the undeniable force, a man who had orchestrated the Klan’s ascent to political
Read MoreArrow right

About The Author

Timothy Egan

Main Quotes

"No one can deny that the United States is a white Protestant country."

"They could join the Ku Klux Klan, their natural brothers in spirit, faith, and Americanism."

"He discovered that if he said something with enough conviction, people would believe it."

"The Klan was a business, and hate was the product."

"The Invisible Empire was a shadow government, a parallel universe of power and intimidation."

"The Klan was a fraternal order, a social club, a self-help group for white Protestants who felt left behind."

"The poison of prejudice, once ingested, is hard to purge."

"The Klan offered a sense of belonging, a feeling of superiority, and a chance to strike back at a world that seemed to be changing too fast."

"In the Klan's twisted logic, patriotism and prejudice were one and the same."

"It was a time of vast fortunes and grinding poverty, of flappers and evangelists, of racial terror and booming cities."

Who Should Read This Book

Readers interested in American history, particularly the history of the Ku Klux Klan.

Individuals interested in social justice and civil rights issues.

Readers of non-fiction books that explore themes of racism, prejudice, and discrimination.

Those interested in true crime stories with a historical context.

Readers of Timothy Egan's previous works.

People interested in the history of the Midwest, especially Indiana.

Individuals who enjoy books about political movements and corruption.

Readers of books that explore the role of women in history.

Book Summaries Like

A Fever in the Heartland
cover backgroundThe Souls of Black Folk

The Souls of Black Folk

W. E. B. Du Bois

In The Souls of Black Folk, W.E.B. Du Bois, a towering figure in American intellectual history, delivers a profound and enduring exploration of race and identity at the dawn of the 20th century. Through a collection of essays that blend sociology, history, and poignant personal narrative, Du Bois captures the essence of the African American experience, grappling with the complexities of "double consciousness"—the sense of always seeing oneself through the eyes of others.

Published in 1903, this seminal work challenges prevailing attitudes and confronts the deep-seated injustices of a nation struggling to reconcile its ideals with the realities of segregation and discrimination. Du Bois offers a powerful critique of Booker T. Washington's accommodationist stance, advocating instead for aggressive activism and the pursuit of higher education as essential pathways to Black liberation and empowerment.

From reflections on the haunting beauty of Black spirituals to searing accounts of racial prejudice, The Souls of Black Folk remains a vital and essential read, offering timeless insights into the ongoing struggle for civil rights and the enduring quest for identity and belonging in a divided America.

cover backgroundAmerican Midnight

American Midnight

Adam Hochschild

In the shadow of World War I, America faced a crisis unlike any other. In American Midnight, Adam Hochschild masterfully unveils a startlingly relevant period between the Great War and the Roaring Twenties, when the very foundations of American democracy were threatened. It was an era of rampant injustice: Black churches burned, dissenters imprisoned for private opinions, vigilantes running wild, and the government itself fanning the flames of repression.

Through vivid storytelling, Hochschild introduces us to the forgotten players of this tumultuous time: from Woodrow Wilson and fiery antiwar voices like Kate Richards O’Hare and Emma Goldman, to labor leader Eugene Debs and a young, ambitious J. Edgar Hoover. American Midnight illuminates a dark chapter of lynchings, censorship, and the abuse of conscientious objectors, revealing the toxic currents of racism, nativism, and contempt for the rule of law that echo in our own era. Discover the harrowing, yet ultimately inspiring, stories of those who fought to redeem a fractured nation, and understand how their struggles continue to shape us today.

cover backgroundThe Gunfighters

The Gunfighters

Bryan Burrough

“One hell of a good read.” — The New York Times “One of the most important books written on the American West in many years.” — True West Magazine From the New York Times bestselling author of The Big Rich and Forget the Alamo comes an epic reconsideration of the time and place that spawned America’s most legendary gunfighters, from Jesse James and Billy the Kid to Butch and Sundance The “Wild West” gunfighter is such a stock figure in our popular culture that some dismiss it all as a corny myth, more a product of dime novels and B movies than a genuinely important American history. In fact, as Bryan Burrough shows us in his dazzling and fast-paced new book, there’s much more below the surface. For three decades at the end of the 1800s, a big swath of the American West was a crucible of change, with the highest murder rate per capita in American history. The reasons behind this boil down to one word: Texas. Texas was born in violence, on two fronts, with Mexico to the south and the Comanche to the north. The Colt revolver first caught on with the Texas Rangers. Southern dueling culture transformed into something wilder and less organized in the Lone Star State. The collapse of the Confederacy and the presence of a thin veneer of Northern occupiers turned the heat up further. And the explosion in the cattle business after the war took that violence and pumped it out from Texas across the whole of the West. The stampede of longhorn cattle brought with it an assortment of rustlers, hustlers, gamblers, and freelance lawmen who carried a trigger-happy honor culture into a widening gyre, a veritable blood meridian. When the first newspapermen and audiences discovered what good copy this all was, the flywheel of mythmaking started spinning. It’s never stopped. The Gunfighters brilliantly sifts the lies from the truth, giving both elements their due. And the truth is sufficiently wild for any but the most unhinged tastes. All the legendary figures are here, and their escapades are told with great flair—good, bad, and ugly. Like all great stories, this one has a rousing end—as the railroads and the settlers close off the open spaces for good, the last of the breed, Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, really do get on a boat for South America, ending their era in a blaze of glory. Burrough knits these histories together into something much deeper and more provocative than simply the sum of its parts. To understand the truth of the Wild West is to understand a crucial dimension of the American story.

cover backgroundEmpire of the Summer Moon

Empire of the Summer Moon

S. C. Gwynne

A Pulitzer Prize finalist, Empire of the Summer Moon chronicles the epic forty-year battle for the American West between white settlers and the Comanche Indians, the most formidable tribe in American history. S.C. Gwynne weaves together two captivating narratives: the rise and fall of the Comanches, whose mastery of horsemanship and warfare halted Spanish and French expansion, and the remarkable story of Cynthia Ann Parker, a captured pioneer girl who became a Comanche woman, and her son Quanah, the last and greatest Comanche chief. More than a history of savage warfare, this is a sweeping account of colonialism, the Civil War, the destruction of the buffalo, and the railroads, revealing how the legendary Comanches shaped the destiny of the American West.

FAQ